Monday, February 18
*Timing subject to change based on the number of teams.
The inaugural Shapero Cup Regional Moot Court Competition (the “Regional”) is scheduled for Monday, February 18, 2019, at the U.S. Bankruptcy Courthouse in Detroit.
The Regional is open to law schools from the Sixth Circuit and is designed in part to serve as formal practice for law school teams competing in the Duberstein Moot Court Competition at St. John’s University School of Law in New York City in March (the “Duberstein Competition”). The Regional is not an elimination round for the Duberstein Competition. Rather, it is an opportunity for the student advocates to hone their skills on the same case problem they will argue in New York. The Shapero Cup will be judged by leading members of the bench and bar.
For the Regional, teams do not need to submit briefs. Each team will argue in the preliminary round, with one argument for the petitioner and one argument for the respondent. The two teams with the highest average score in the preliminary round will advance to the final round.
Awards will be given at the Regional, which will include the Shapero Cup for the first-place team and a plaque for the top oralist.
Allison R. Bach
Dickinson Wright PLLC
Michael E. Baum
Schafer & Weiner, PLLC
Office of the U.S. Trustee
Ian Bolton Law Group
Office of the U.S. Trustee
Sean M. Cowley
Office of the U.S. Trustee
Maxwell Dunn, PLC
Lisa Sommers Gretchko
Howard & Howard
Wallace M. Handler
Sullivan, Ward, Asher & Patton, P.C.
David A. Lerner
Plunkett Cooney, P.C.
Craig S. Schoenherr, Sr.
O'Reilly Rancilio P.C.
Hon. Phillip J. Shefferly, Chief Judge
U.S. Bankruptcy Court (E.D. Mich.)
QUALIFICATIONS/NATURE OF EVENT
Any accredited law school located in the Sixth Circuit (Michigan, Kentucky, Ohio and Tennessee) may enter one or two teams to participate in the Regional. The event is designed to serve as formal practice for the Sixth Circuit law schools that are competing in the 2019 Duberstein Competition.
NUMBER AND COMPOSITION OF TEAMS
Each participating school may enter up to two teams composed of two or three students each. All team members must be enrolled at the school that they represent at the time of the competition.
SUBSTITUTION OF TEAM MEMBERS
There shall be no substitution of team members after the Application Form is submitted, except upon written permission from the Regional.
There shall be no brief submissions for the Regional. Competitors are scored on oral advocacy only.
- IN GENERAL. Each team will argue in the preliminary round, with one argument for the petitioner and one argument for the respondent. The two teams with the highest scores in the preliminary round will advance to the final round.
- PAIRINGS OF TEAMS. Pairings in the preliminary round will be chosen at random.
- TIME AND PLACE. Oral arguments will take place on February 18, 2019, at the U.S. Bankruptcy Courthouse in Detroit.
ANNOUNCEMENT OF WINNING TEAM
The winner of the 2019 Shapero Cup will be announced at the Awards Reception.
The scores for each round will be based on oral argument.
LENGTH OF ARGUMENTS
Each team is limited to thirty (30) minutes of oral argument. Two (2) team members will argue in each round. How the thirty (30) minutes allotted for the argument is divided among team members may be made at the discretion of the team, but no team member shall be apportioned less than ten (10) minutes for oral argument. The petitioner may reserve up to three (3) minutes of rebuttal time prior to the commencement of the argument. Teams that reserve rebuttal time shall notify the judges and/or bailiff on how to deduct rebuttal time. Time reserved for rebuttals shall be counted as part of the thirty (30) minutes allotted for the argument. Judges reserve the right to allow for additional time at their discretion.
BEST ORAL ADVOCATE
The competitor with the highest mean (average) score for oral argument will be chosen as the best oral advocate. The winner of the best oral advocate award will be announced at the Awards Reception.
ATTENDING OTHER ARGUMENTS
No team member, coach or faculty adviser of a team participating in the Regional may attend an argument of any other team during the preliminary round. The number of attendees to each argument is limited to the competing team members, their families, and two coaches or two faculty advisors. All participants may attend, and are strongly encouraged to attend, the final round.
COMMUNICATION DURING ROUNDS
There shall be no communication in any form from any member of the audience, including other team members sitting in the audience, once a round has begun.
The Regional may assess such penalties, including disqualification, as it deems reasonable and appropriate for any failure to comply with the foregoing rules. Any decisions, penalties or other actions taken by the Regional will be final and binding on all participants. The Regional reserves the right to make and implement any further rules and procedures deemed advisable for the conduct of this event.
Bethany Spencer, CMP
American Bankruptcy Institute
Case Western Reserve University
Michigan State University (2 teams)
The Ohio State University
University of Memphis (2 teams)
University of Michigan
Gold Lange & Majoros, P.C.
Hon. Steven Rhodes (Ret.)
Wolfson Bolton PLLC
For sponsorship opportunities, please download the form and return to Bethany Spencer.